Australian employers don’t have to pay superannuation to workers under 18 who put in less than 30 hours in a week, a carve-out that has sat in the law since compulsory super began in the 1990s. A parliamentary inquiry is now examining a Greens-led push to scrap it, with Greens senator Barbara Pocock putting the cost at $411 million a year across 530,000 teenage workers. For anyone running apprentices, the number that decides it is 30: a young worker on a full-time roster is already owed super, a school-based apprentice doing a day or two on site generally isn’t.

The debate was set out by The Sydney Morning Herald, which reports unions, super funds and the Greens pushing for the exclusion to go, while business groups warn about cost and timing. Labor changed its party platform this year to back super for under-18s regardless of hours worked.

Why the carve-out exists, and why that argument has worn thin

When compulsory super came in, the reasoning was practical. Tiny balances got chewed through by administration fees and insurance premiums, so a kid with $300 in an account could end up with nothing.

Pocock, who has a private senator’s bill to remove the exclusion, argues that logic no longer holds, because fee caps now apply to low-balance accounts and insurance premiums are no longer automatically deducted from young workers’ accounts.

She has described the current rules as a “clear case of legislated age-based discrimination that no longer has any defensible policy rationale”.

“clear case of legislated age-based discrimination that no longer has any defensible policy rationale”

“Every year, 530,000 young teenage workers are denied the astonishing sum of $411 million in super for no reason other than their age”, Pocock said this year.

The Super Members’ Council, which represents funds, told the debate that a typical teenager working two years might build about $2000 in super by their 18th birthday, and that money could be worth around $10,000 by retirement. That’s compounding doing the heavy lifting over 45-odd years, not a windfall.

Where apprentices and young site workers actually sit

This is where the trades differ from the retail and hospitality jobs that dominate the coverage.

The test is hours, not job title. A 17-year-old serving an apprenticeship on a standard full-time week is well clear of the 30-hour line, so super is already payable on their ordinary earnings in the normal way, alongside the apprentice wage rates that apply by state and year. Nothing in the Greens bill changes that.

The ones caught by the carve-out are the part-timers. A school-based apprentice splitting the week between classroom and site, a Year 11 kid doing Saturdays in the yard sorting formply and sweeping out, a casual labourer picking up two shifts a week over the holidays. On those rosters, hours usually land under 30 and the exemption applies.

A handwritten timesheet and pen on the dashboard of a work ute
For under-18 part-timers, hours logged each week decide whether super is payable. Illustration: Blue Collar News

That matters for the way a lot of small builders bring young people through. The Saturday yard hand who turns into a first-year is a well-worn path into becoming a carpenter, and under the current rules those first months carry no super at all. Change the law and the cost of that trial period goes up by the super guarantee rate on every hour worked.

If you’ve got an under-18 on the books and you’re not sure which side of the line they fall on, the super guarantee rules are set out by the Australian Taxation Office, and the hours test is the thing to check against your timesheets rather than your memory.

Business groups call the timing “terrible”

The resistance isn’t really about the principle. It’s about what it costs to put on a 16-year-old right now.

Kevin Hogan, the Coalition’s shadow minister for financial services, says the timing of such a change would be “terrible” because the small businesses that employ many young people are already dealing with higher costs.

“If Labor is serious about helping young Australians, they should ask the Productivity Commission to look at what this change would mean for youth employment, small businesses and retirement outcomes before rushing ahead”, Hogan says.

The Australian Retail Council has warned of “unintended consequences” from anything that makes hiring young people more expensive, the Herald reports. Retailers are also absorbing a lift in labour costs after this year’s Fair Work Commission ruling that workers aged 18 to 20 in sectors including fast food and retail be paid the same as their older colleagues.

Assistant Treasurer Daniel Mulino has said he supports the change, but that it’s a matter of when.

A teenage worker stacking timber in a builder's yard
Saturday yard work is a common way into carpentry, and it usually falls under the 30-hour line. Illustration: Blue Collar News

On who ultimately wears the cost, the Grattan Institute has previously found that workers pay for the bulk of super through lower-than-otherwise wages. In the short run, though, it lands on the employer’s payroll run, and that’s what shapes a hiring decision in February when you’re deciding whether to take on one junior or two.

Youth unemployment is the number holding it up

Labour force figures reported by the Herald last week put youth unemployment, covering 15 to 24-year-olds, at 11.3 per cent last month, up from 11.1 per cent, the highest reading since 2021 and more than double the 4.9 per cent rate across the wider workforce. Monthly labour force data is published by the Australian Bureau of Statistics.

That’s the figure business groups will put in front of the inquiry, and it’s a fair one to put. When work tightens, the first thing a small builder stops doing is bringing on new starters, and that falls hardest on the youngest.

The Herald’s analysis argues the answer is a phased change rather than a sudden one, on the basis that “it’s not a good time” can’t justify a two-tier system forever, but that the hiring risk is real. Compulsory super for everyone else was lifted in steps over years, not overnight.

What to watch

Three things. Whether the inquiry recommends removing the hours test outright or phasing it in. Whether the government attaches a start date to its in-principle support. And whether any change comes with lead time long enough to price into apprentice intakes before the first-year wave in January.

If you employ school-based apprentices or casual juniors, a phase-in is the difference between a known cost you can quote into jobs and a mid-year surprise on the payroll. Worth keeping an eye on the inquiry’s reporting date.

Frequently asked questions

Do apprentices get superannuation under current law?

Full-time apprentices already qualify for super like any other employee. The exemption only applies to under-18 workers, including school-based apprentices and casual juniors, who work less than 30 hours a week.

What is the 30-hour rule for super?

Employers don’t have to pay super to workers under 18 who work fewer than 30 hours in a week, regardless of job title. The test is based on hours worked on the roster, not whether someone is an apprentice or casual.

Is the super carve-out for under-18s being scrapped?

A Senate inquiry is examining a Greens bill to remove the exemption. Labor has changed its platform to back the change in principle, but Assistant Treasurer Daniel Mulino says it’s a question of timing rather than principle.


Sourced from The Sydney Morning Herald. Original article.